Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christian Gonzalez's avatar

i'm not gonna defend the rats with their weird sex stuff but people need to chill about pdku. i was a fellow there and the vibe was literally just adult summer camp

people really want pdku to have been something it wasn’t. listen, i’m too trad-lite and constitutionally optimistic to needlessly defend the rats: i’m neither a fan of the sex stuff nor am i an ai doomer. but people are reaching extraordinarily hard to shoehorn this event into some preconceived narrative they have in their head for various motivated reasons. by all means criticize the rats, you will find me among your allies in many cases, but not here

pdku was, in my experience, exactly what it said on the label: an attempt to advocate for their preferred cause area to the general public. they did this by bringing in various creators, new and established, to hopefully make videos on x-risk. there was no requirement to fit a narrative nor to even make videos about x-risk at all, and many didn’t. in fact, essentially all of my videos were *critical* of x-risk arguments. organizer aella's partner and MIRI president Nate Soares even willingly came on my podcast to debate x-risk with me for an hour

i will admit, the rats did get annoyed when i challenged their assumptions, but no more than anyone gets annoyed when you poke at their foundational beliefs. at the very least they were always willing and eager to talk things out. for all their faults the rats are, again in my experience, earnest

and while we’re on the topic, let me put this to rest once and for all: no, there was no weird sex stuff organized by the rats. it was just a bunch of creators hanging out and making videos for a month. it was an absolute blast and i would do it again in a heartbeat

Strange Ian's avatar

I'm continually taken aback by how much influence it's possible to acquire over the course of world events just by being a highly motivated narcissist who writes a lot.

You make the apt comparison to Lenin but I always think Yudkowsky is strikingly similar to Marx - never has a real job, just a weird egomaniac who's convinced that only he knows the secret to history, sits in a room and thinks until he's developed an apocalyptic narrative backed by a vast body of esoteric jargon the main purpose of which is to increase the amount of reading you have to do to debunk him. And in both cases of course it's a religious narrative translated into godless materialist terms so it'll be compelling to people who would instinctively reject spiritual ones.

Scott Alexander here is kind of Yudkowsky's Engels. Engels when you read him is much easier to follow than Marx - like he takes Marx at face value but also is sort of dutifully translating him into simpler terms so he can make more sense of it.

I don't really understand though why so many people are so gullible. Don't you just look at the guy for one second and go "hang on a minute, what was that about rape again?" and then immediately write off everything he has to say? I get the way these things work is that the cult puts in vastly more effort than any reasonable person would expect in order to maintain power - you can see that from the massive Scott effortposts and the way there's always someone ready to jump in the way of every criticism, presumably all co-ordinated in various group chats beforehand. Still seems odd though that they've been able to seize control such a gigantic proportion of the American AI industry. Very much a weird feature of our time.

71 more comments...

Ready for more?